Monthly newsletter published by McLellan's Automotive History 

Dedicated to literature collectors, restorers, museums, publishers,
manufacturers and investors who collect and preserve automotive literature
HOME | share your story | media | use of content | subscribe | letters to the editor | contact us  
Ask a Question
Name: State / Country: *Question:
*E-mail: Tel: Subscribe: Yes No                     
 L I T E R A T U R E
I N D E X
Click here
 
Editor-in-Chief
Mona Nath
Technical Editor
Robert McLellan
Photo Editor
Anil Nath
:: LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
  LITERATURE INVESTMENTS
:: Personal Insights
:: Literature Life
:: Looking Both Ways
:: Golden Eras
:: Good Investment? - Yes!
:: Buying For Tomorrow
:: Good Investment?
:: Profitable Portfolio!
:: Unanticipated Investment
:: Tomorrow's Treasure
:: What Is It Worth?
  CONCEPTS & RUMORS
:: GM Concepts
:: The Future: 70 years ago
:: Annual Concepts
:: Concepts — 1930s
:: Fisher Body Craftsman
:: GM Probes The Future
:: Book review: John Jacobus' Inside the Fisher Body Craftsman’s Guild
:: Winter Reading
:: Maserati: The Panini Collection
:: Bridgehampton Racing: From The Streets To The Bridge
:: Small Cars
:: Duntov's Secret - Corvette Gulf Oil Race Car
:: Sports Cars Then and Now
:: 50% Off Press Kit Sale
:: They Started in MGs
:: The American Automotive Assembly Line
:: Peugeot in Review
:: Big Rigs Rolling
:: Damn Few Died In Bed
:: Auto Paint History and Chips
:: Bill Horton's 'Jezebelle'
:: Chevrolet Trucks
:: Coachbuilder's Renderings
:: British Quality
:: Book review: American Road Racing: 1948 - 1950, The Sport Revived
:: Something Different
:: Teaching Kids about the Hobby
:: Restorations Literature
:: Chrysler Corporation in the 1970s
:: Renault 1939 - 1971
:: Book review: American Road Racing - The 1930s
:: The War Years: 1940s
:: The Serious Collector
:: Mercury's Cool Cat
:: Build It Yourself
:: Tell your story
:: Memorabilia by Make
:: Citroen - Introducing Front Wheel Drive
:: The Memorable 1950s
:: Book: Caribbean Capers
:: Hidden Literature
:: 1965 Cadillac Sedan DeVille
:: Checker Motors
:: Porsche 911 Evolution
:: Technical Automotive Literature
:: Jaguar's Racing Heritage
:: Special Cars: 1975-1995
:: GMC Trucks
:: Vauxhall in England - GM Overseas - 1
:: Opel in Germany - GM Overseas - 2
:: Packard: Ask the Man Who Owns One
:: 1901 Ford Sweepstakes - The Race Car That Changed Everything
:: School Bus Literature
:: Concept Cars
:: Popular Pickups
:: Family Firebird
:: The Winners Book
:: American Postwar Dropouts
:: Japanese Literature of The 1960s
:: Favorite Press Kits
:: Selecting your literature
:: Cars for professionals
:: Collectible Automobile Literature
:: From Airplanes to Super Cars
:: The British Contribution
:: Press Kit Bonanza
:: American Light Trucks in Literature
:: GM in the 1950s
:: Octavia and Felicia
:: English Ford
:: Maintaining the MGB in the 21th Century, Barrie Jones, 2009
:: Leader Card Racers - A Dynasty of Speed, Gordon Eliot White, 2009
:: Fun on Wheels
:: Prestige, Status & Works of Art, Selling The Luxury Car 1888 - 1942
:: Chassis 141: The Story of the First LeMans Bentley
:: German Luxury: Two Thoroughbreds & Their Lifestyle
:: Top 10 Collector Cars for 2010-2020
:: An Introduction to Collecting Car Brochures
:: Subcompact automobile: Ford Fiesta
:: Out-of-print-book: A Century of Automotive Style
:: My Auto Literature Collection
:: Automotive Magazines
:: Plymouth 1935-1936
:: History of the Corvette
:: Preservation of literature
:: Z. Taylor Vinson - An era ends
:: Hendrick Motorsports Museum
:: Happy 50th Birthday Corvair!
:: Diamond T
:: Rolls-Royce for India's royalty
:: Original Paint Chips
:: Pontiac Dream Cars of 1953, 1954 & 1955
:: Wallace Wyss - Artist Profile
:: America's Packard Museum
:: Ford's Road Leads To Mustang
:: My Super Beetle
:: Citroen SM (1970)
:: Unanticipated Investment
:: Quality Control
:: How To Decide Which Car You Should Restore
:: The End of the Affair
:: Printed brochures soon to be a memory?
:: Don't Forget Dealer Literature
:: Automotive Books
:: The Fisher Body Craftsman's Guild — An Illustrated History
:: GM Concepts
:: Change Creates Nostalgia
:: Racing (Part 1)
:: Collecting Automotive Literature
:: Investing in Literature
:: Pre-World War II Brochures
:: Showroom Postcards — 1930s through 1950s
:: Ferrari SP1. More Than Unique
:: Fiat
:: The Making of Shelby Cars in Detail
:: Unusual Postcards
:: German Press Kits
:: Everything Cadillac
:: Plymouth Nostalgia
:: Loving Mercedes-Benz Quality
:: Dealer Posters
:: Mercury's Glory Years
:: Racing & Show Programs
:: Buyer's Guide To Brochures
:: 356 Porsche Literature FAKES!
:: Ford Trucks
:: Books And Magazines
:: The Best Increase in Value the Most
:: The Making of a Ford Collection
:: Austins
:: Cars and Literature of the 1970s
:: First Impressions
:: Electric Vehicles
:: Goodbye Viper
:: Land Rover
:: Collectibles vs. Recession
:: See a Classic Car Show, Take a Nostalgia Trip
:: Times Are Changing...
:: Lamborghini's
:: Collectible Tractors
:: From Boxy to Fins
:: How I Met John Conlon
:: One Historian Mourns the Passing of the Black and White Glossy
:: Thanks Dad!
:: My Story
:: Review: Two Press booklets on the Rolls Phantom Drophead coupe
:: Collecting for Fun and Relaxation
:: Rolls-Royce and Bentley
:: Packing for Shipping
:: Dodge Trucks
:: The Family Station Wagon
:: Collecting 'Down Under'
:: Owner's Manuals
:: Press Kit Review
:: "Buy Me a Ferrari"
:: Your Literature
:: MG in America
:: Dealer Stamps
:: Commercial Vehicles
:: Ask the Man Who Owns One
:: Enhance Your Collection
:: The Early Books
:: Triumph
:: Coachbuilder's Literature
:: Wolseley
:: International Opportunities
:: The Innovative Hudson
:: Chevrolet Literature
:: Buses/Engines/Fire Trucks/Tractors/Trains...
:: The Schödel Collection
:: Beyond the Mustang II
:: Kaiser-Frazer
:: Sunbeam & Sunbeam-Talbot
:: The Dawn of the Auto
:: Taxi Cabs, Police Cars & Emergency Vehicles
:: U.S. Postwar Econocars
:: Jaguar in the 1950s
:: Inquiring Minds
:: Exotic Dropouts
:: Rare Maserati Find
:: The Beautiful Brute
:: Dune Buggy/ATV Escapes
:: Remembering Oldsmobile
:: Original Paint Chips
:: Vintage Bentleys
:: Trucks of the 1930s and 1940s
:: BMW
:: Collecting Memories
:: Auto Books - 50 Years
:: Imperial is Back
:: Mitchel DeFrancis: Automobilia Enthusiast
:: Lincoln As Art
:: The Golden Age of Press Kits
:: Iron Curtain Literature
:: Toyota Sports
:: Planning an Advertising Campaign
:: Happy Halloween
:: Styled — For — Tomorrow
:: Automotive Archeology
:: Paint, Upholstery, Data & More
:: 14 Steps: From Our Shop To Your Maildrop
:: Cadillac Memories
:: British Luxury
:: My IHC Fever
:: A Collector's Story - Fifty Years and Counting
:: 1907 "Washington Times" Race
:: Postwar Studebaker
:: The Popularity of AMC / Nash / Rambler
:: Mazda Miata Memories
:: 2020 'Think Tank' Results
:: Letteratura Di Automobile
:: Magazines Are Literature
:: Camaro Fever
:: Grandad's Cars
:: Star Cars — Year 2020
:: Australian Auto Literature
:: Jeep History
:: Porsche on Parade
:: David Greeney: Automobilia Collector
:: Building Dreams
:: Flathead V-8 Fords
:: The Japanese Invasion
:: Touring India
:: Auto Shows
:: The Buick Flashback
:: Meeting Tarun Thakral
:: The Mysterious Dale
:: Ford Overseas
:: Swedish Brothers
:: Pre-War Orphans
:: Pinto or Corvette?
:: Fisher Body Craftsman's Guild
:: Rick Lenz - 10 Years Later
:: Best of Buick
:: Comments on Packing
:: Diamond T
:: 1959+
:: AC In The News — AAA
:: Getting Home Alive!
:: Motorizing The Army
:: Posters & Transparencies as Automotive Art
:: Contemporary Automotive Photographs
:: Convertible Fever
:: French Auto Literature
:: MoPaR
:: Automobile Quarterly Collections
:: History of the Ambulance
:: Oddities
:: The Traveling Salesman
:: Ultra Luxury
:: Finnish Brochures
:: Postcard Paradise
:: Limited Editions
:: German Thoroughbreds
:: Auto Galleria LUCE
:: Fisher Guild Reunion
:: Them VS. Us
:: The Corvair Legend
:: RR - World's Best Car
:: Recreational Vehicles
:: Datsun Z Literature
:: Ford Flower Power
:: News You Can Use
:: Connoisseurs' Choice
:: Automotive Books
:: Pate's Hidden Treasure
:: Every Boy's Dream
:: Jeep Literature As Art
:: My Beloved Hillman
:: Adios Cuba
:: Reprint News
:: British Sports Cars
:: International Customers
:: Corvette: A Legend
:: Automotology
:: Literature In Norway
:: Salvage Literature
:: Volkswagen As Art
:: Brass Era Literature
:: Society: Auto Historians
:: Pontiac Art: Insights
:: Truck Literature?
:: Quality Control
:: Bentley
:: The Exotics
:: Kit Cars & Replica Cars
:: Pontiacs as Art
:: High Speed Pursuits
:: Robert's Tips
:: Honest Reprint Lit
:: Literature on Lincoln
:: Dealer Stamps
:: Original or Fake?
:: The Rolls-Royce
:: Counterfeit Literature
:: World of Auto Literature
:: Z. Taylor Vinson
:: Junichiro Hiramatsu
:: Ed Whitt
 
 
 
July 2009 Issue
 
ARTICLE
 
The End of the Affair
By P.J. O’Rourke
 

The fate of Detroit isn’t a matter of economics. It’s a tragic romance, whose magic was killed by bureaucrats, bad taste and busybodies. P.J. O’Rourke on why Americans fell out of love with the automobile.

 

The phrase “bankrupt General Motors,” which we expect to hear uttered on Monday (i.e June 1, 2009), leaves Americans my age in economic shock. The words are as melodramatic as “Mom’s nude photos.” And, indeed, if we want to understand what doomed the American automobile, we should give up on economics and turn to melodrama.

Politicians, journalists, financial analysts and other purveyors of banality have been looking at cars as if a convertible were a business. Fire the MBAs and hire a poet. The fate of Detroit isn’t a matter of financial crisis, foreign competition, corporate greed, union intransigence, energy costs or measuring the shoe size of the footprints in the carbon. It’s a tragic romance — unleashed passions, titanic clashes, lost love and wild horses.

Foremost are the horses. Cars can’t be comprehended without them. A hundred and some years ago Rudyard Kipling wrote “The Ballad of the King’s Jest,” in which an Afghan tribesman avers: Four things greater than all things are, — Women and Horses and Power and War.

Click for larger view

Insert another “power” after the horse and the verse was as true in the suburbs of my 1950s boyhood as it was in the Khyber Pass.

Horsepower is not a quaint leftover of linguistics or a vague metaphoric anachronism. James Watt, father of the steam engine and progenitor of the industrial revolution, lacked a measurement for the movement of weight over distance in time — what we call energy. (What we call energy wasn’t even an intellectual concept in the late 18th century — in case you think the recent collapse of global capitalism was history’s most transformative moment.) Mr. Watt did research using draft animals and found that, under optimal conditions, a dray horse could lift 33,000 pounds one foot off the ground in one minute. Mr. Watt — the eponymous watt not yet existing — called this unit of power “1 horse-power.”

In 1970 a Pontiac GTO (may the brand name rest in peace) had horsepower to the number of 370. In the time of one minute, for the space of one foot, it could move 12,210,000 pounds. And it could move those pounds down every foot of every mile of all the roads to the ends of the earth for every minute of every hour until the driver nodded off at the wheel. Forty years ago the pimply kid down the block, using $3,500 in saved-up soda-jerking money, procured might and main beyond the wildest dreams of Genghis Khan, whose hordes went forth to pillage mounted upon less oomph than is in a modern leaf blower.

Click for larger view

Horses and horsepower alike are about status and being cool. A knight in ancient Rome was bluntly called “guy on horseback,” Equesitis. Chevalier means the same, as does Cavalier. Lose the capitalization and the dictionary says, “insouciant and debonair; marked by a lofty disregard of others’ interests, rights, or feelings; high-handed and arrogant and supercilious.” How cool is that? Then there are cowboys — always cool — and the U.S. cavalry that coolly comes to their rescue plus the proverbially cool-handed “Man on Horseback” to whom we turn in troubled times.

Early witnesses to the automobile urged motorists to get a horse. But that, in effect, was what the automobile would do — get a horse for everybody. Once the Model T was introduced in 1908 we all became Sir Lancelot, gained a seat at the Round Table and were privileged to joust for the favors of fair maidens (at drive-in movies). The pride and prestige of a noble mount was vouchsafed to the common man. And woman, too. No one ever tried to persuade ladies to drive sidesaddle with both legs hanging out the car door.

For the purpose of ennobling us schlubs, the car is better than the horse in every way. Even more advantageous than cost, convenience and not getting kicked and smelly is how much easier it is to drive than to ride. I speak with feeling on this subject, having taken up riding when I was nearly 60 and having begun to drive when I was so small that my cousin Tommy had to lie on the transmission hump and operate the accelerator and the brake with his hands.

A 1950 Studebaker Commander Convertible, with its famous
‘bullet-nose’ front end.

Click for larger view

After the grown-ups had gone to bed, Tommy and I shifted the Buick into neutral, pushed it down the driveway and out of earshot, started the engine and toured the neighborhood. The sheer difficulty of horsemanship can be illustrated by what happened to Tommy and me next. Nothing. We maneuvered the car home, turned it off and rolled it back up the driveway. (We were raised in the blessedly flat Midwest.) During our foray the Buick’s speedometer reached 30. But 30 miles per hour is a full gallop on a horse. Delete what you’ve seen of horse riding in movies. Possibly a kid who’d never been on a horse could ride at a gallop without killing himself. Possibly one of the Jonas Brothers could land an F-14 on a carrier deck.

Thus cars usurped the place of horses in our hearts. Once we’d caught a glimpse of a well-turned Goodyear, checked out the curves of the bodywork and gaped at that swell pair of headlights, well, the old gray mare was not what she used to be. We embarked upon life in the fast lane with our new paramour. It was a great love story of man and machine. The road to the future was paved with bliss.

Then we got married and moved to the suburbs. Being away from central cities meant Americans had to spend more of their time driving. Over the years away got farther away. Eventually this meant that Americans had to spend all of their time driving. The play date was 40 miles from the Chuck E. Cheese. The swim meet was 40 miles from the cello lesson. The Montessori was 40 miles from the math coach. Mom’s job was 40 miles from Dad’s job and the three-car garage was 40 miles from both.

The car ceased to be object of desire and equipment for adventure and turned into office, rec room, communications hub, breakfast nook and recycling bin — a motorized cup holder. Americans, the richest people on Earth, were stuck in the confines of their crossover SUVs, squeezed into less space than tech-support call-center employees in a Mumbai cubicle farm. Never mind the six-bedroom, eight-bath, pseudo-Tudor with cathedral-ceilinged great room and 1,000-bottle controlled-climate wine cellar. That was a day’s walk away.

Henry Ford and his Model T.

Click for larger view

We became sick and tired of our cars and even angry at them. Pointy-headed busybodies of the environmentalist, new urbanist, utopian communitarian ilk blamed the victim. They claimed the car had forced us to live in widely scattered settlements in the great wasteland of big-box stores and the Olive Garden. If we would all just get on our Schwinns or hop a trolley, they said, America could become an archipelago of cozy gulags on the Portland, Ore., model with everyone nestled together in the most sustainably carbon-neutral, diverse and ecologically unimpactful way.

But cars didn’t shape our existence; cars let us escape with our lives. We’re way the heck out here in Valley Bottom Heights and Trout Antler Estates because we were at war with the cities. We fought rotten public schools, idiot municipal bureaucracies, corrupt political machines, rampant criminality and the pointy-headed busybodies. Cars gave us our dragoons and hussars, lent us speed and mobility, let us scout the terrain and probe the enemy’s lines. And thanks to our cars, when we lost the cities we weren’t forced to surrender, we were able to retreat.

But our poor cars paid the price. They were flashing swords beaten into dull plowshares. Cars became appliances. Or worse. Nobody’s ticked off at the dryer or the dishwasher, much less the fridge. We recognize these as labor-saving devices. The car, on the other hand, seems to create labor. We hold the car responsible for all the dreary errands to which it needs to be steered. Hell, a golf cart’s more fun. You can ride around in a golf cart with a six-pack, safe from breathalyzers, chasing Canada geese on the fairways and taking swings at gophers with a mashie.

Louis Chevrolet sits behind the wheel of his prototype car in 1911.

Click for larger view

We’ve lost our love for cars and forgotten our debt to them and meanwhile the pointy-headed busybodies have been exacting their revenge. We escaped the poke of their noses once, when we lived downtown, but we won’t be able to peel out so fast the next time. In the name of safety, emissions control and fuel economy, the simple mechanical elegance of the automobile has been rendered ponderous, cumbersome and incomprehensible. One might as well pry the back off an iPod as pop the hood on a contemporary motor vehicle. An aging shade-tree mechanic like myself stares aghast and sits back down in the shade. Or would if the car weren’t squawking at me like a rehearsal for divorce. You left the key in. You left the door open. You left the lights on. You left your dirty socks in the middle of the bedroom floor.

I don’t believe the pointy-heads give a damn about climate change or gas mileage, much less about whether I survive a head-on with one of their tax-sucking mass-transit projects. All they want to is to make me hate my car. How proud and handsome would Bucephalas look, or Traveler or Rachel Alexandra, with seat and shoulder belts, air bags, 5-mph bumpers and a maze of pollution-control equipment under the tail?

And there’s the end of the American automobile industry. When it comes to dull, practical, ugly things that bore and annoy me, Japanese things cost less and the cup holders are more conveniently located.

The American automobile is — that is, was — never a product of Japanese-style industrialism. America’s steel, coal, beer, beaver pelts and PCs may have come from our business plutocracy, but American cars have been manufactured mostly by romantic fools. David Buick, Ransom E. Olds, Louis Chevrolet, Robert and Louis Hupp of the Hupmobile, the Dodge brothers, the Studebaker brothers, the Packard brothers, the Duesenberg brothers, Charles W. Nash, E. L. Cord, John North Willys, Preston Tucker and William H. Murphy, whose Cadillac cars were designed by the young Henry Ford, all went broke making cars. The man who founded General Motors in 1908, William Crapo (really) Durant, went broke twice. Henry Ford, of course, did not go broke, nor was he a romantic, but judging by his opinions he certainly was a fool.

Preston Tucker, in one of the few Tucker cars produced, celebrates being acquitted of charges of fraud over the failure of his automobile business in 1950.

Click for larger view

America’s romantic foolishness with cars is finished, however, or nearly so. In the far boondocks a few good old boys haven’t got the memo and still tear up the back roads. Doubtless the Obama administration’s Department of Transportation is even now calculating a way to tap federal stimulus funds for mandatory OnStar installations to locate and subdue these reprobates.

Among certain youths — often first-generation Americans — there remains a vestigial fondness for Chevelle low-riders or Honda “tuners.” The pointy-headed busybodies have yet to enfold these youngsters in the iron-clad conformity of cultural diversity’s embrace. Soon the kids will be expressing their creative energy in a more constructive way, planting bok choy in community gardens and decorating homeless shelters with murals of Che.

I myself have something old-school under a tarp in the basement garage. I bet when my will has been probated, some child of mine will yank the dust cover and use the proceeds of the eBay sale to buy a mountain bike. Four things greater than all things are, and I’m pretty sure one of them isn’t bicycles. There are those of us who have had the good fortune to meet with strength and beauty, with majestic force in which we were willing to trust our lives. Then a day comes, that strength and beauty fails, and a man does what a man has to do. I’m going downstairs to put a bullet in a V-8.

P.J. O’Rourke is the author of 13 books, including “Driving Like Crazy.”

 

P.J. O'Rourke points out the obvious future that awaits is one of small, economical hybrids and electric cars that will replace today's cars. But just like in the mid-1970s, when high gasoline prices, environmental controls, safely features and inflation resulted in high-priced cars and poor quality, we had to endure what we drove instead of enjoying what we drove. But there are still some enjoyable cars being built. And there will be in the future. Just fewer and fewer.

On the positive side, the cause does have an effect. What happened in 1970s grew in the 1980s, 1990s and is still growing. The old car hobby has blossomed and now will grow even more, long into the future. Those old cars that O'Rourke appreciates are still with us and more are being restored ever day because now they are more desirable than ever.

Don't be sad and decide to give up on the real enthusiast cars. Get one if you do not own one already. The place to start looking is McLellan's Automotive History where you can do some research and collecting — over 150,000 brochures, books, dealer albums, paint chips, press kits, memorabilia, handbooks, manuals, etc. A good investment in O'Rourke's future.  — Robert Mclellan

 
 
 
Source: The Wall Street Journal, U.S. - May 30, 2009
 
 
  R E A D E R S   C O M M E N T S  
 

Excellent article. I agree on many but not all points. It took three decades for the "muscle cars" to come back after the fuel crisis and onslaught of government regulation in the 1970's. How long will it take this time? I'm not sure. But I do believe they will return again, as soon as technology makes it possible. Automobiles are still a form of personal expression for many Americans, and I don't believe that will ever change.

David Lantz - June 28, 2009

 
     
 
 
     
 

Thanks for running PJ O'Rourke's The End of the Affair in July's issue of The Automotive Chronicles. PJ is one of my favorite writers. Although in this instance I don't quite share his viewpoint, I certainly feel his pain.

Peter Kraus - June 23, 2009

 
 
 
 
The Automotive Chronicles, July 2009
 
 
 
 
 
Literature for
OVER 600 MAKES